Mystery Box - 2 Item Hats Findlay Hats
Mystery Box - 2 Item Hats Findlay Hats

Mystery Box - 2 Item

"I’ve purchased countless mystery hats and love every single one."

- Mitchell H.

$ 34.99 USD
Free Shipping Lifetime Warranty Satisfaction

Our 2-Item Mystery Box 


Not picky? Want the best value? The Mystery Box may be a perfect choice! All Mystery Boxes come with a random assortment of Findlay products - including unreleased, current & discontinued models.

2 random Findlay items - up to 60% off!

Choose from your choice of Snapback (standard flat brim style), Dad Hat (bent bill), or 5-panel (camper) hat. 

Each box is chosen at random and contains two randomly selected Findlay products. Guaranteed to come with one snapback, dad hat, or 5-panel and either a beanie or sun Cheaters

No exchange policy. 

Due to the heavily discounted prices, free shipping, and the random nature of the selection, our free returns & exchange policy does not cover Mystery Boxes. 

Are you picky?

We do our best to ensure a nice diverse set of products in each box - and we want you to be happy with your purchase! That said if you are looking for a specific cap, your best bet is to purchase that specific hat!



If there is an item in the box you know you will not have any use for, please mention that in the special notes section and our team will do our best to make sure to not include that item. Even with this note, you may still receive that item as inventory options for boxes is limited. 


Thank you for understanding and we are sure you will enjoy it!

The photo & video demonstrate a sample of what could come in your mystery box - each box is different and contains an assortment of different items.

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 180 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • hats
  • mystery box
  • Findlay
  • quality
  • sunglasses
  • guys
  • experience
  • items
  • beanie
  • customer service
Frank S.
United States

Amazing Company & Service!!!

So happy I found this company & these beautifully made hats! Customer service is fantastic! Truly a company to watch out for!!!!

Michael C.
United States United States


I love the design on every hat and ordering is quick and easy. Shipping is great with tracking the whole way. After my first hat order I can't stop ordering lol

Jacob H.
United States United States

Great product

Amazing, great customer service for their products and I love my hat and stickers!! I’m hooked and can’t wait to get more!

Hollis H.
United States United States

Great hat; better service

I'm not a hat guy, but this is the most comfortable one I've ever had. The compliments I get are just icing on the cake. Jimmy and the crew were in contact throughout the manufacturing and shipping process, and I couldn't be happier. Don't be surprised if my coworkers order a few!

Hannah T.
United States United States

The Best

Took my chance on a mystery hat to see how I would like it and ended up loving what I got so much!!! It was definitely worth it and will more than likely get another in the future!