Mystery Hat Hat of the month Findlay Hats
Mystery Hat Hat of the month Findlay Hats Mystery Hat Hat of the month Findlay Hats
$ 24.99 USD
Free Shipping Satisfaction


The best bang for your buck on the Findlay site! Snag a single mystery cap for just $24.99, or subscribe to our mystery Hat Of the Month and get a mystery hat mailed to your door each month for just $19.99! 


  • 1 Mystery Hat, monthly
  • Billed Monthly
  • Free US Shipping

Customer Reviews

Based on 77 reviews Write a review
Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 82 Reviews
Write a Review Ask a Question
  • Reviews
  • Questions

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • Findlay
  • mystery hat
  • hats
  • color
  • experience
  • idea
  • Saturn
  • craftsmanship
  • customer
  • something
Jimmy T.
United States United States
Mystery? Surprise me!

Absolutely love the thrill of ordering a mystery hat and never being let down!

Findlay Hats Mystery Hat Review
United States United States
Fantastic subscription

Easiest $20 you can spend. Bangers mailed to your door every month.

Findlay Hats Mystery Hat Review
Amanda B.
United States United States
My fave hat

This has become my go to hat overall I love the fade and colorway and it goes with so many diff shades of blue....this was like an unknown unicorn for me

Findlay Hats Mystery Hat Review
Gabriel P.
United States United States
Very nice

I was intimidated by the idea of a mystery hat and the possibility of not liking it. Turns out it’s pretty nice. Every mystery hay I have gotten, I have loved. And I love the price too.

George M.
United States United States
Mystery hat of the month

What a cool experience. It was my first experience with the Findlay mystery box, and I was super impressed. It's an absolute steal! For $20 you can't beat one of these amazing hats. Combine that with the great community in the BST on Facebook and you can experience all the great headwear that's been made.

Findlay Hats Mystery Hat Review